Post-Ureteroscopic Lesion Scale: limitaciones en su aplicabilidad clínica / Post-Ureteroscopic Lesion Scale to determine ureteral wall damage, not so easy to employ

Objetivo Analizar el nivel de concordancia de la Post-Ureteroscopic Lesion Scale (PULS), y examinar las consecuencias de su aplicación en la práctica clínica con datos estadísticos más fiables que los utilizados en el trabajo original. Métodos Se realizaron 14 ureteroscopias (URS) y 14 micro-ureteroscopias (micro-URS) en 14 cerdos hembra. Todos los procedimientos se grabaron en vídeo y se realizó un análisis anatomopatológico en cada uréter. Dieciséis urólogos (9 endourólogos y 7 urólogos generales) y 4 médicos internos residentes evaluaron las lesiones ureterales según la escala PULS, con grados 0, 1 y ≥2. La concordancia se calculó mediante porcentajes, el Coeficiente W de Kendall, el índice kappa de Fleiss y el alfa de Krippendorff. La concordancia entre evaluadores se calculó con la Correlación de Spearman y el Coeficiente kappa de Cohen. Resultados El porcentaje de concordancia fue del 11,1%. Los coeficientes se clasificaron como bajos o muy bajos, y encontramos una mayor concordancia entre los evaluadores más inexpertos. Por otro lado, no hubo acuerdo entre el 50% de los evaluadores. Conclusiones La baja concordancia entre evaluadores, la especificidad de la PULS y la correlación clínico/patológica sugieren dificultades del uso de esta escala y una curva de aprendizaje probablemente larga. (AU)

Objective To analyze the level of agreement of the Post-Ureteroscopic Lesion Scale (PULS) and the consequences on its application in clinical practice with more reliable statistical data than the one used in the original work. Methods 14 URS and 14 micro-URS were performed in 14 female porcine model. All the procedures were video recorded and an anatomopathological analysis was performed in each ureter. Sixteen urologists (9 endourologists and 7 general urologists) and 4 residents evaluated the ureteral lesions according to the PULS, with degrees 0, 1 and ≥2. The agreement was calculated with percentages, Kendall's W coefficient and the indicators Fleiss’ Kappa and Krippendorff's Alpha, while the inter-rater agreement was calculated with Spearman's correlation and Cohen's Kappa. Results The percent of agreement was 11.1%. The coefficients were likewise classified as low or very low, with the greatest agreement found among the inexperienced. Also, 50% of the raters did not agree with the rest. Conclusions The low inter-rater agreement, the specificity of the PULS and the clinical-pathological correlation suggests that this scale is not simple, and probably has a long learning curve. (AU)

Post-Ureteroscopic Lesion Scale to determine ureteral wall damage, not so easy to employ.

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the level of agreement of the Post-Ureteroscopy Lesion Scale (PULS) and the consequences on its application in clinical practice with more reliable statistical data than the one used in the original work. METHODS: 14 URS and 14 micro-URS were performed in 14 female porcine model. All the procedures were video recorded and an anatomopathological analysis was performed in each ureter. Sixteen urologists (9 endourologists and 7 general urologists) and 4 residents evaluated the ureteral lesions according to the PULS, with degrees 0, 1 and ≥2. The agreement was calculated with percentages, Kendall's W coefficient and the indicators Fleiss' Kappa and Krippendorff's Alpha, while the inter-rater agreement was calculated with Spearman's correlation and Cohen's Kappa. RESULTS: The percent of agreement was 11.1%. The coefficients were likewise classified as low or very low, with the greatest agreement found among the inexperienced. Also, 50% of the raters did not agree with the rest. CONCLUSIONS: The low inter-rater agreement, the specificity of the PULS and the clinical-pathological correlation suggests that this scale is not simple, and probably has a long learning curve.

Inter-observer agreement on levels of evidence in radiology articles.

Levels of evidence (LE) are established through a hierarchical classification of studies according to their design. At present, there are many heterogeneous LE classifications, and this hampers their applicability. Our study aims to identify which LE classification has the best interobserver concordance for radiology articles. For this purpose, an interobserver agreement analysis were performed on 105 original articles applying two NE scales (Oxford Center of Evidence Based Medicine (OCEBM) y National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC)). The inter-rater agreement of the LE assigned after reading the abstracts was good when using the OCEBM scale (K = 0.679), and somewhat lower with the NHMRC (K = 0.577 -moderate-). All differences were statistically significant (P < .000). So, in conclusion, of the two scales analysed (OCEBM and NHMRC), the OCEBM led to the strongest level of inter-rater agreement.

Effect of M-wave Amplitude on Inter-evaluator Concordance and Number of Detected Innervation Zones in the Medial Gastrocnemius Using Multichannel Electromyography / Efecto de la Amplitud de la Onda M sobre la Concordancia entre Evaluadores y el Número de Zonas de Inervación Detectadas en el Gastrocnemio Medial Mediante Electromiografía Multicanal

SUMMARY: The Innervation Zones (IZ) correspond to clusters of neuromuscular junctions. The traditional method of locating IZs through voluntary muscle contractions may not be feasible in individuals with motor disorders. Imposed contractions by electrostimulation are an alternative. However, there is limited evidence regarding the factors that affect inter-evaluator concordance and the number of localized IZs when using imposed contraction. The main objective of this research was to determine the effect of the amplitude of compound motor action potentials (CMAPs) containing the M-wave on inter-evaluator agreement. As a secondary objective, was investigate the effect on the number of detected IZs. Twenty-four healthy volunteers (age: 21.2 ± 1.5years, weight: 67.4 ± 13.2kg, height: 1.68 ± 0.80m) participated in the study. Electrostimulation was applied to the tibial nerve to induce contraction of the medial gastrocnemius. The IZ were identified based on the M-wave recorded through multichannel electromyography. A receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis was conducted to assess sensitivity and specificity in detecting the IZs. Inter-rater agreement was evaluated using a two-way mixed effects test to determine the intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). A p-value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant. The ROC analysis revealed that for both evaluators, a specificity of 95% was achieved with an amplitude ≥30 %. The area under the ROC curve was 0.980 [0.964, 0.996], indicating a strong influence of CMAP amplitude on detection of IZs. The highest level of agreement (ICC = 0.788 [0.713, 0.844]) among the evaluators was observed with CMAP amplitudes equal to or greater than 80 % of the maximum M-wave. The findings of this study demonstrate that both the number and the inter-evaluator concordance for detecting IZs using imposed contractions are strongly influenced by the amplitude of the M-wave. Higher M-wave amplitudes were associated with improved concordance and increased IZ detection, making it crucial to standardize amplitude settings for reliable outcomes.

Las Zonas de Inervación (IZ) corresponden a grupos de uniones neuromusculares. El método tradicional para localizar IZs mediante contracciones musculares voluntarias puede no ser factible en personas con trastornos motores. Las contracciones impuestas mediante electro estimulación son una alternativa. Sin embargo, existe poca evidencia sobre los factores que afectan la concordancia entre evaluadores y el número de IZs localizadas al usar este tipo de contracciones. El objetivo de esta investigación fue determinar el efecto de la amplitud de los potenciales de acción motores compuestos (PAMCs) que contienen la onda M sobre la concordancia entre evaluadores. Como objetivo secundario, se investigó el efecto sobre el número de IZs detectadas. Veinticuatro voluntarios sanos (edad: 21.2 ± 1.5 años, peso: 67.4 ± 13.2 kg, altura: 1.68 ± 0.80 m) participaron en el estudio. Se aplicó electroestimulación al nervio tibial para inducir la contracción del gastrocnemio medial. Las IZs se identificaron según la onda M registrada mediante electromiografía multicanal. Se realizó un análisis de curva de las característica del receptor (ROC) para evaluar la sensibilidad y especificidad en la detección de las IZs. La concordancia entre evaluadores se evaluó utilizando una prueba de efectos mixtos de dos vías para determinar los coeficientes de correlación intraclase (ICC). Se consideró un valor de p menor que 0.05 como estadísticamente significativo. El análisis ROC reveló que para ambos evaluadores se logró una especificidad del 95% con una amplitud ≥30 %. El área bajo la curva ROC fue de 0.980 [0.964, 0.996], lo que indica una fuerte influencia de la amplitud del CMAP en la detección de las IZs. El nivel más alto de concordancia (ICC = 0.788 [0.713, 0.844]) entre los evaluadores se observó con amplitudes de CMAP iguales o mayores al 80 % de la onda M máxima. Los hallazgos de este estudio demuestran que tanto el número como la concordancia entre evaluadores para detectar IZs mediante contracciones impuestas están fuertemente influenciados por la amplitud de la onda M. Las amplitudes más altas de la onda M se asociaron con una concordancia mejorada y un aumento en la detección de IZs, lo que hace crucial estandarizar los ajustes de amplitud para obtener resultados confiables.

[Interobserver agreement in the diagnosis of bladder outlet obstruction in women]. / Variabilidad interobservador en el diagnóstico de obstrucción del tracto de salida vesical en mujeres.

Background: The diagnosis of bladder outlet obstruction (BOO) in women is a challenge for functional urology. In Mexico there are few data that report the prevalence of OTSV in women, being up to 24% in a group of patients. Objective: The aim of this study is to compare six different definitions of bladder outlet obstruction and evaluate the interobserver agreement in an educational setting. Material and Methods: Urodynamic studies (UDS) of women with and without diagnosis of BOO were retrospectively assesed. Farrar, Chassagne, Lemack, Defreitas, Blavais and Groutz, Solomon-Greenwell definitions were evaluated. All UDS were independently reviewed by 5 observers. The easiest, the hardest and the fastest were chosen. Interobserver agreement to classify the patients as obstructed was assessed by kappa reliability statistical analysis. We classified the type of mistakes the participants made; error of interpretation and miscalculation. Results: A total of 28 urodynamic studies were reviewed. All observers had a substantial agreement (0.64-0.78) to classify BOO using all but Lemack and Solomon-Greenwell definitions. A total 120 errors from 840 responses were found; 45.8% errors of interpretation of UDS and 54.1% miscalculation of the equation. Finally, all the participants chose the Solomon-Greenwell was the most difficult definition. Conclusion: Chassagne, Defreitas and Farrar definitions proved substantial interobserver agreement. Solomon-Greenwell and Lemack´s definitions had the highest number of pitfalls and the lowest level of agreement.

Introducción: el diagnóstico de obstrucción de tracto de salida vesical (OTSV) en mujeres supone un reto para la urología funcional. En México existen pocos datos que reporten la prevalencia de OTSV en mujeres, siendo de hasta el 24% en un grupo de pacientes. Objetivo: comparar seis definiciones diferentes de obstrucción de tracto de salida vesical (OTSV) en mujeres y evaluar la concordancia entre observadores en un entorno educativo. Material y métodos: evaluación retrospectiva de estudios urodinámicos de mujeres con y sin diagnóstico de OTSV. Se evaluaron las definiciones de Farrar, Chassagne, Lemack, Defreitas, Blavais y Groutz y Solomon-Greenwell. A todos los participantes se les brindó un taller teórico-práctico para analizar los estudios urodinámicos en su fase de flujo-presión y diagnosticar la OTSV. Los estudios urodinámicos fueron revisados de forma independiente por cinco observadores. La concordancia interobservador para clasificar a los pacientes como obstruidos se evaluó mediante análisis estadístico de confiabilidad kappa. Se clasificó el tipo de errores que cometieron los participantes, error de interpretación de estudios urodinámicos y error de cálculo en los criterios. Resultados: se revisaron en total 28 estudios urodinámicos. Todos los observadores tuvieron una concordancia buena de (0.64-0.78) para clasificar OTSV usando todas las definiciones excepto las de Lemack y Solomon-Greenwell. Se encontraron un total de 120 errores de 840 respuestas, 45.8% errores de interpretación y 54.1% error de cálculo de la ecuación. Los participantes eligieron la definición de Solomon-Greenwell, la más difícil. Conclusión: las definiciones de Chassagne, Defreitas y Farrar demostraron una concordancia sustancial entre observadores. Las definiciones de Solomon-Greenwell y Lemack tuvieron el mayor grado de dificultad y el menor nivel de acuerdo.

Agreement between pharmacists and physicians on the assessment of appropriateness of antimicrobial prescribing.

INTRODUCTION: Audits for monitoring the quality of antimicrobial prescribing are a main tool in antimicrobial stewardship programs; however, interobserver reliability has not been conclusively assessed. Our objective was to measure the level of agreement between pharmacists and physicians on the appropriateness of antimicrobials prescribing in hospitals. METHODS: A national multicenter, cross-sectional study was conducted of patients who were receiving antimicrobials one day of April 2021. Hospital participation was voluntary, and the study population was randomly selected. Pharmacists and physicians performed a simultaneous, independent assessment of the quality of antimicrobial prescriptions. The observers used an assessment method by which all indicators of the quality of antimicrobial use were considered. Finally, an algorithm was used to rate overall antimicrobial prescribing as appropriate, suboptimal, inappropriate, or not assessable. Gwet's AC1 coefficient was used to assess interobserver agreement. RESULTS: In total, 101 hospitals participated, and 411 hospital antimicrobial prescriptions were reviewed. The strength of agreement was moderate regarding the overall quality of prescribing (AC1=0.51; 95%CI=[0.44-0.58]). A very good level of agreement (AC1>0.80) was observed between pharmacists and physicians in all indicators of the quality, except for duration of treatment, rated as good (AC1=0.79; 95%CI=[0.75-0.83]), and registration on the medical record, rated as fair (AC1=0.34; 95%CI=[0.26-0.43]). The agreement was greater in critical care, onco-hematology, and pediatric units than in medical and surgery units. CONCLUSIONS: In this point prevalence study, a moderate level of agreement was observed between pharmacists and physicians in the evaluation of the appropriateness of antimicrobials prescribing in hospitals.

Protocolización de estudios clínicos multicéntricos en la era digital. ¿Tiene utilidad la centralización de datos por un data-manager? / Protocolization of multicenter clinical studies in the digital era. Is useful data centralization by a data-manager?

Introducción En los estudios multicéntricos la protocolización de los datos es una fase crítica que puede generar sesgos, sobre todo en estudios clínicos con presupuesto limitado. El objetivo es analizar la concordancia y la confiabilidad de los datos obtenidos en un estudio multicéntrico clínico entre la protocolización del centro de origen y la protocolización centralizada mediante un data-manager. Método Estudio clínico multicéntrico de prevalencia nacional sobre un carcinoma familiar infrecuente, realizándose una doble protocolización de los datos: a)en el centro de origen, y b)centralizada con un data-manager. La concordancia se analiza para el global de los datos y para los dos subgrupos del proyecto: a)grupo a estudio (carcinoma familiar; protocolizan 30 investigadores) y b)grupo control (carcinoma esporádico; protocolizan 4). Las diferencias interobservador se evalúan mediante el índice de Kappa de Cohen. Resultados Se incluyen 689 pacientes: 252 del grupo a estudio y 437 del grupo control. Respecto al análisis de concordancia del estadio tumoral, se han objetivado un 2,5% de discordancias, siendo alta la concordancia entre protocolizadores (Kappa=0,931). Respecto a la valoración del riesgo de recidiva, las discordancias fueron del 7% de los casos, siendo alta la concordancia (Kappa=0,819). Respecto a la clasificación ecográfica TIRADS, las discordancias son del 6,9% y la concordancia es alta (Kappa=0,922). Se han detectado un 4,6% de errores de transcripción. Conclusiones En los estudios multicéntricos clínicos la protocolización centralizada de los datos por un data-manager parece presentar resultados similares a la protocolización directa en la base de datos en el centro de origen. (AU)

Introduction In multicenter studies, the protocolization of data is a critical phase that can generate biases. The objective is to analyze the concordance and reliability of the data obtained in a clinical multicenter study between the protocolization in the center of origin and the centralized protocolization of the data by a data-manager. Methods National multicenter clinical study about an infrequent carcinoma. A double protocolization of the data is carried out: (i)center of origin; and (ii)centralized by a data manager. The concordance between the data is analyzed for the global data and for the two groups of the project: (i)study group (familiar carcinoma, 30 researchers protocolize); (ii)control group (sporadic carcinoma, 4 people protocolize). Interobserver variability is evaluated using Cohen's kappa coefficient. Results The study includes a total of 689 patients with carcinoma: 252 in the study group and 437 in the control group. Regarding the concordance analysis of the tumor stage, 2.5% of disagreements were observed and the concordance between people who protocolize was near perfect (Kappa=0.931). Regarding the evaluation of the recurrence risk, disagreements occurred in 7% of the cases and the concordance was near perfect (Kappa=0.819). Regarding the sonography evaluation (TIRADS), the disagreements were 6.9% and the concordance was near perfect (Kappa=0.922). Also, 4.6% of transcription errors were detected. Conclusions In multicenter clinical studies, the centralized data protocolization by a data-manager seems to present similar results to the direct protocolization in the database in the center of origin. (AU)

Protocolization of multicenter clinical studies in the digital era. Is useful data centralization by a data-manager?

INTRODUCTION: In multicenter studies, the protocolization of data is a critical phase that can generate biases.The objective is to analyze the concordance and reliability of the data obtained in a clinical multicenter study between the protocolization in the center of origin and the centralized protocolization of the data by a data -manager. METHODS: National multicenter clinical study about an infrequent carcinoma. A double protocolization of the data is carried out: (a) center of origin; and (b) centralized by a data manager: The concordance between the data is analyzed for the global data and for the two groups of the project: (a) study group (Familiar carcinoma, 30 researchers protocolize); (b) control group (Sporadic carcinoma, 4 people protocolize). Interobserver variability is evaluated using Cohen's kappa coefficient. RESULTS: The study includes a total of 689 patients with carcinoma, 252 in the study group and 437 in the control group. Regarding the concordance analysis of the tumor stage, 2.5% of disagreements were observed and the concordance between people who protocolize was near perfect (Kappa = 0.931). Regarding the evaluation of the recurrence risk, disagreements occurred in 7% of the cases and the concordance was near perfect (Kappa = 0.819). Regarding the sonography evaluation (TIRADS), the disagreements were 6.9% and the concordance was near perfect (Kappa = 0.922). Also, 4.6% of transcription errors were detected. CONCLUSIONS: In multicenter clinical studies, the centralized data protocolization o by a data-manager seems to present similar results to the direct protocolization in the database in the center of origin.

Agreement between incisional and excisional biopsies for hormone receptors and her2 in breast cancer.

INTRODUCTION: Breast cancer is the leading cause of cancer mortality in Mexican women. OBJECTIVE: The objective of the study was to identify concordances among core needle biopsy (CNB) and excisional biopsies (EB) regarding diagnosis, hormonal receptors (HR), and human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (Her2). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Core number, demographic data, histological type, and treatment were documented for each sample. Reported HR and Her2 score from both samples were compiled. RESULTS: 70 women with both CNB/EB were included. Median age was 58 (36-87) years; initial diagnosis in CNB were invasive ductal 56 (80%), lobular 10 (14%), and mixed 4 (6%) carcinomas. Diagnostic agreement among CNB and EB was of 97%, k = 0.65. A concordance of 92% (k = 0.75), 75% (k = 0.26), and 67% (k = 0.46) was observed for estrogen receptors, progesterone receptors, and Her2 determinations, and positive predictive values in CNB were 0.96, 0.89, and 0.44, respectively. CONCLUSION: HR and Her2 concordances using manual-immunohistochemistry (IHC) were found within the range of values obtained using automatized-IHC. When compared to tumor heterogeneity, technical/reading errors contribute more to discordances.

INTRODUCTION: El cáncer de mama es la principal causa de mortalidad por cáncer en mujeres mexicanas. OBJETIVO: Identificar la concordancia entre la biopsia con aguja de corte (BAC) y la biopsia escisional (BE) con respecto al diagnóstico, receptores hormonales (RH) y Her2. MATERIAL Y MÉTODOS: Se registró el número de fragmentos cilíndricos, datos demográficos, tipo histológico y tratamiento. Se recopilaron resultados de RH y Her2. RESULTADOS: Se incluyeron 70 mujeres con mediana de edad de 58 años. El diagnóstico inicial en BAC fue carcinoma ductal invasivo 56 (80%), lobular 10 (14%) y mixtos 4 (6%). El acuerdo de diagnóstico entre BAC y BE fue del 97%, k = 0.65. Se observó una concordancia de 92% (k = 0.75), 75% (k = 0.26) y 67% (k = 0.46) para las determinaciones de receptor de estrógenos (RE), receptor de progesterona (RP) y Her2, y los valores predictivos positivos en BAC fueron 0.96, 0.89 y 0.44, respectivamente. CONCLUSIÓN: Los RH y la concordancia de Her2 mediante inmunohistoquímica (IHC) manual se encuentran dentro del rango de valores obtenidos mediante el uso de IHC automatizada. Los errores técnicos/de lectura contribuyeron más a discordancia que la heterogeneidad tumoral.

Guías antieméticas: ¿hemos incorporado los cambios referentes a carboplatino y antraciclinas? / Antiemetic guidelines: Have we incorporated the changes concerning carboplatin and anthracyclines?

Objetivo: en 2016 se publicaron las guías de la MASCC/ESMO que incorporaron los esquemas de antraciclinas como quimioterapia altamente emetógena (QAE) proponiendo la triple terapia antiemética, así como para los esquemas de carboplatino. Los objetivos fueron analizar el nivel de concordancia entre las guías y la profilaxis antiemética utilizada en el hospital de día de hematooncología, evaluar su efectividad y determinar el ahorro de la inclusión de netupitant/palonosetrón (NEPA) oral con dexametasona intravenosa (NEPAd) respecto a fosaprepitant con ondansetrón y dexametasona (FOD intravenosa). Método estudio observacional prospectivo registrando variables demográficas, esquema de quimioterapia recibido, localización tumoral, riesgo emetógeno del paciente, pauta antiemética prescrita, concordancia con guía MASCC/ESMO y su efectividad, utilización de medicación de rescate y registro de visitas a urgencias o ingresos por emesis.Se llevó a cabo un estudio farmacoeconómico de minimización de costes. Resultados se incluyeron 61 pacientes, 70% mujeres, mediana edad 60,5.Los esquemas de platino fueron más frecuentes en el periodo 1, siendo el 87,5% respecto al 67,6% en el periodo 2. Los esquemas con antraciclinas fueron del 21,6 y 10% respectivamente en cada periodo. Un 21,1% de las pautas antieméticas no coincidían con las recomendaciones MASCC/ESMO, siendo en su totalidad en el periodo 1. La puntuación de los cuestionarios de efectividad fue de protección total en el 90,9% en las náuseas agudas, del 100% en los vómitos agudos y en las náuseas retardadas, y del 72,7% en los vómitos retardados. La frecuencia de uso de medicación de rescate fue del 18,7% en el periodo 1 y no fue necesaria en el periodo 2.No se detectaron visitas a urgencias ni ingresos en ninguno de los periodos. El uso de NEPAd comportó una reducción del 28% de los costes con respecto al empleo de FOD. Conclusiones: ... (AU)

Objective: Latest MASCC/ESMO guidelines of the recommendations for the prophylaxis of acute and delayed emesis induced by moderately emetogenic chemotherapy was published in 2016 incorporating anthracycline schemes as highly emetogenic chemotherapy (HEC), proposing triple antiemetic therapy to control nausea and vomiting. Likewise, they recommend triple therapy for carboplatin. The objectives of this study were to analyze the degree of concordance between guidelines and antiemetic prophylaxis used in the Chemotherapy Outpatient Unit in patients undergoing treatment with HEC and carboplatin, to evaluate its effectiveness and to determine the savings due to the use of netupitant/palonosetron (NEPA) oral (or) with intravenous (iv) dexamethasone (NEPAd) compared to iv Fosaprepitant with ondansetron and dexamethasone (FOD iv).MethodsProspective observational study recording demographic variables, chemotherapy protocol, tumor location, patient emetogenic risk, antiemetic regimen prescribed, concordance with the MASCC/ESMO guideline, and effectiveness, evaluated by MASCC survey, use of rescue medication and visits to the Emergency Department or hospitalization due to emesis.A cost minimization pharmacoeconomic study was carried out. Results 61 patients were included; 70% women; median age 60.5. Platinum schemes were more frequent in period 1, being 87.5% compared to 67.6% in period 2. Anthracycline schemes were 21.6% and 10% respectively in each period.A 21.1% of the antiemetic regimens did not coincide with the MASCC/ESMO recommendations, being entirely in period 1. The score of the effectiveness questionnaires was total protection in 90.9% in acute nausea, from 100% in acute vomiting and delayed nausea, and 72.7% in delayed vomiting.The frequency of use of rescue medication was 18.7% in period 1 and was not necessary in period 2.No visits to the emergency room or admissions were detected in any of the periods. Conclusions: ...(AU)

Tomografía computarizada coronaria en urgencias: importancia de la experiencia del radiólogo / Coronary computed tomography in emergencies: the importance of the radiologist's experience

Introducción: La incorporación de la angiografía coronaria por tomografía computarizada (ACTC) a la atención sanitaria en las urgencias hospitalarias hace necesaria una adecuada capacitación para la interpretación de esta prueba de imagen. Esta capacitación puede afectar al grado de concordancia interobservador de los radiólogos que evalúan dichos estudios. Objetivo: Evaluar la concordancia interobservador en función de la experiencia en la interpretación de ACTC realizadas a pacientes que acuden a urgencias por dolor torácico agudo (DTA) con probabilidad baja-intermedia de síndrome coronario agudo (SCA). Materiales y método: Estudio de concordancia interobservador en la evaluación de ACTC realizadas en contexto urgente utilizando CAD-RADS como registro de resultados. Se crearon parejas de observadores entre un total de 8 evaluadores (4 staff y 4 en formación). Se estimó el grado de concordancia global y entre subgrupos de acuerdo con su experiencia mediante el coeficiente kappa. Resultados: La concordancia fue sustancial entre radiólogos experimentados y en formación (k= 0,627; IC95%: 0,436-0,826), así como para todas las parejas de evaluadores (k=0,661; IC95%: 0,506-0,823) para todas las categorías CAD-RADS en conjunto. El grado de acuerdo del grupo de radiólogos experimentados fue superior al de los radiólogos en formación en todos los análisis realizados. La concordancia fue excelente para CAD-RADS global (k= 0,950; IC95%: 0,896-1) y para CAD-RADS ≥ 4 (k = 1), observando un menor acuerdo para CAD-RADS ≥ 3 (k= 0,754; IC95%: 0,246-1,255). Los valores del personal en formación para estas categorías fueron k= 0,623, k= 0,596 y k= 0,473, respectivamente. Conclusión: La concordancia entre radiólogos staff en la evaluación de ACTC realizadas a pacientes en el contexto de urgencias es excelente. El grado de acuerdo es menor cuando el personal inexperto forma parte de las parejas analizadas...(AU)

Introduction: Incorporating coronary computed tomography angiography (CTA) in the hospital workup for suspected acute coronary syndrome requires appropriate skills for interpreting this imaging test. Radiologists’ skills can affect the interobserver agreement in evaluating these studies. Objective: To determine the interobserver agreement according to radiologists’ experience in the interpretation of coronary CTA studies done in patients who present at the emergency department with acute chest pain and low-to-intermediate probability of acute coronary syndrome. Materials and methods: We studied the interobserver agreement in the urgent evaluation of coronary CTA studies in which CAD-RADS was used to register the findings. We created pairs of observers among a total of 8 assessors (4 attending radiologists and 4 radiology residents). We used the kappa coefficient to estimate the overall concordance and the concordance between subgroups according to their experience. Results: The agreement was substantial between experienced radiologists and residents (k = 0.627; 95%CI: 0.436 – 0.826) as well as between all the pairs of observers (k=0.661; 95%CI: 0.506 – 0.823) for all the CAD-RADS together. The degree of agreement within the group of experienced radiologists was greater than that within the group of residents in all the analyses. The agreement was excellent for the overall CAD-RADS (k=0.950; 95% CI: 0.896 – 1) and for CAD-RADS ≥ 4 (k=1); the agreement was lower for CAD-RADS ≥ 3 (k = 0.754; 95% CI: 0.246 – 1.255). The agreement for the residents for these categories was k= 0.623, k=0.596, and k=0.473, respectively. Conclusion: The agreement among attending radiologists regarding the assessment of urgent coronary CTA studies is excellent. The agreement is lower when residents are paired with attending radiologists...(AU)

Coronary computed tomography in emergencies: The importance of the radiologist's experience.

INTRODUCTION: Incorporating coronary computed tomography angiography (CTA) in the hospital workup for suspected acute coronary syndrome requires appropriate skills for interpreting this imaging test. Radiologists' skills can affect the interobserver agreement in evaluating these studies. OBJECTIVE: To determine the interobserver agreement according to radiologists' experience in the interpretation of coronary CTA studies done in patients who present at the emergency department with acute chest pain and low-to-intermediate probability of acute coronary syndrome. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We studied the interobserver agreement in the urgent evaluation of coronary CTA studies in which CAD-RADS was used to register the findings. We created pairs of observers among a total of 8 assessors (4 attending radiologists and 4 radiology residents). We used the kappa coefficient to estimate the overall concordance and the concordance between subgroups according to their experience. RESULTS: The agreement was substantial between experienced radiologists and residents (k=0.627; 95%CI: 0.436-0.826) as well as between all the pairs of observers (k=0.661; 95%CI: 0.506-0.823) for all the CAD-RADS together. The degree of agreement within the group of experienced radiologists was greater than that within the group of residents in all the analyses. The agreement was excellent for the overall CAD-RADS (k=0.950; 95% CI: 0.896-1) and for CAD-RADS ≥ 4 (k=1); the agreement was lower for CAD-RADS ≥ 3 (k=0.754; 95% CI: 0.246-1.255). The agreement for the residents for these categories was k=0.623, k=0.596, and k=0.473, respectively. CONCLUSION: The agreement among attending radiologists regarding the assessment of urgent coronary CTA studies is excellent. The agreement is lower when residents are paired with attending radiologists. These findings should be taken into consideration when implementing coronary CTA in emergency departments and in the organisation of radiological staff for interpreting and reporting this imaging test.

[Translated article] Have changes concerning carboplatin and anthracyclines been incorporated?

OBJECTIVE: Latest MASCC/ESMO guidelines of the recommendations for the prophylaxis of acute and delayed emesis induced by moderately emetogenic chemotherapy was published in 2016 incorporating anthracycline schemes as highly emetogenic chemotherapy (HEC), proposing triple antiemetic therapy to control nausea and vomiting. Likewise, they recommend triple therapy for carboplatin. The objectives of this study were to analyze the degree of concordance between guidelines and antiemetic prophylaxis used in the Chemotherapy Outpatient Unit in patients undergoing treatment with HEC and carboplatin, to evaluate its effectiveness and to determine the savings due to the use of netupitant/palonosetron (NEPA) oral (or) with intravenous (iv) dexamethasone (NEPAd) compared to iv Fosaprepitant with ondansetron and dexamethasone (FOD iv). METHODS: Prospective observational study recording demographic variables, chemotherapy protocol, tumor location, patient emetogenic risk, antiemetic regimen prescribed, concordance with the MASCC/ESMO guideline, and effectiveness, evaluated by MASCC survey, use of rescue medication and visits to the Emergency Department or hospitalization due to emesis. A cost minimization pharmacoeconomic study was carried out. RESULTS: 61 patients were included; 70% women; median age 60.5. Platinum schemes were more frequent in period 1, being 87.5% compared to 67.6% in period 2. Anthracycline schemes were 21.6% and 10% respectively in each period. A 21.1% of the antiemetic regimens did not coincide with the MASCC/ESMO recommendations, being entirely in period 1. The score of the effectiveness questionnaires was total protection in 90.9% in acute nausea, from 100% in acute vomiting and delayed nausea, and 72.7% in delayed vomiting. The frequency of use of rescue medication was 18.7% in period 1 and was not necessary in period 2. No visits to the emergency room or admissions were detected in any of the periods. CONCLUSIONS: Use of NEPAd led to a 28% reduction in costs with respect to the use of FOD. A high level of concordance was obtained in both periods between the latest published guideline and healthcare practice in our field. Surveys carried out on patients seem to suggest that both antiemetic therapies have similar effectiveness in clinical practice. The inclusion of NEPAd has led to a reduction in costs, positioning itself as an efficient option.

Antiemetic guidelines: Have we incorporated the changes concerning carboplatin and anthracyclines? / Guías antieméticas: ¿hemos incorporado los cambios referentes a carboplatino y antraciclinas?

OBJECTIVE: Latest MASCC/ESMO guidelines of the recommendations for the prophylaxis of acute and delayed emesis induced by moderately emetogenic chemotherapy was published in 2016 incorporating anthracycline schemes as highly emetogenic chemotherapy (HEC), proposing triple antiemetic therapy to control nausea and vomiting. Likewise, they recommend triple therapy for carboplatin. The objectives of this study were to analyze the degree of concordance between guidelines and antiemetic prophylaxis used in the Chemotherapy Outpatient Unit in patients undergoing treatment with HEC and carboplatin, to evaluate its effectiveness and to determine the savings due to the use of netupitant/palonosetron (NEPA) oral (or) with intravenous (iv) dexamethasone (NEPAd) compared to iv Fosaprepitant with ondansetron and dexamethasone (FOD iv). METHODS: Prospective observational study recording demographic variables, chemotherapy protocol, tumor location, patient emetogenic risk, antiemetic regimen prescribed, concordance with the MASCC/ESMO guideline, and effectiveness, evaluated by MASCC survey, use of rescue medication and visits to the Emergency Department or hospitalization due to emesis. A cost minimization pharmacoeconomic study was carried out. RESULTS: 61 patients were included; 70% women; median age 60.5. Platinum schemes were more frequent in period 1, being 87.5% compared to 67.6% in period 2. Anthracycline schemes were 21.6% and 10% respectively in each period. A 21.1% of the antiemetic regimens did not coincide with the MASCC/ESMO recommendations, being entirely in period 1. The score of the effectiveness questionnaires was total protection in 90.9% in acute nausea, from 100% in acute vomiting and delayed nausea, and 72.7% in delayed vomiting. The frequency of use of rescue medication was 18.7% in period 1 and was not necessary in period 2. No visits to the emergency room or admissions were detected in any of the periods. CONCLUSIONS: Use of NEPAd led to a 28% reduction in costs with respect to the use of FOD. A high level of concordance was obtained in both periods between the latest published guideline and healthcare practice in our field. Surveys carried out on patients seem to suggest that both antiemetic therapies have similar effectiveness in clinical practice. The inclusion of NEPAd has led to a reduction in costs, positioning itself as an efficient option.

Coeficiente de correlación intraclase / Intraclass correlation coefficient

El coeficiente de correlación intraclase permite medir la concordancia general entre dos o más mediciones que implican variables de carácter cuantitativo, obtenidas estas con diferentes instrumentos de medida o evaluadores. Se basa en un modelo de análisis de varianza con medidas repetidas. Su uso solo es posible si existe normalidad de las distribuciones de las variables, igualdad de varianzas e independencia entre los errores producidos por los observadores (AU)

The intraclass correlation coefficient makes it possible to measure the general concordance between two or more measurements that involve variables of a quantitative nature, obtained with different measuring instruments or evaluators. It is based on an analysis of variance model with repeated measures. Its use is only possible if there is normality of the distributions of the variables, equality of variances and independence between the errors produced by the observers (AU)

[Intraclass correlation coefficient]. / Coeficiente de correlación intraclase.

The intraclass correlation coefficient makes it possible to measure the general concordance between two or more measurements that involve variables of a quantitative nature, obtained with different measuring instruments or evaluators. It is based on an analysis of variance model with repeated measures. Its use is only possible if there is normality of the distributions of the variables, equality of variances and independence between the errors produced by the observers.

Concordancia entre diferentes observadores en la evaluación de las restauraciones dentales en radiografías panorámicas / Agreement among different observers in the evaluation of dental restorations in panoramic radiographs

El objetivo fue evaluar la concordancia entre dife-rentes docentes del Hospital Odontológico Universi-tario de la Facultad de Odontología de la Universidad de Buenos Aires en la evaluación de restauraciones dentales en radiografías panorámicas. Se diseñó un formulario ad-hoc basado en los criterios de Ryge modificados. Se construyeron cinco categorías: pre-sencia y tipo (R), extensión (E), y condición (C), de cada restauración; situación respecto de tratamientos endodónticos (EN) y presencia y tipo de anclaje intra-rradicular (A). Después de diferentes reuniones vir-tuales de calibración con ajustes correspondientes en el formulario, se seleccionaron al azar veinticinco radiografías panorámicas de la base de datos de la Cátedra de Diagnóstico por Imágenes. Tres observa-dores aplicaron en forma simultánea e independien-te las categorías a tres piezas (1.1, 1.3 y 1.6) en cada radiografía. La concordancia se evaluó con Kappa de Fleiss por categoría y por diente/categoría. Resulta-dos: categoría/diente(IC95%): R:1.1: 0,96 (0,90-1,2), 1.3: 0,77 (0,56-0,99), 1.6: 0,92 (0,80-1,03); E: 1.1: 0,92 (0,85-1), 1.3: 0,89 (0,73-1,04), 1.6: 0,92 (0,80-1,03); C: 1.1: 0,88 (0,78-0,98), 1.3: 0,74 (0,38-1,10), 1.6: 1 (1-1); EN: 1.1 y 1.3: 1 (1-1), 1.6: 0.90 (0.77-1.04); A: 1.1 y 1.6: 1 (1-1), 1,3: 0,88 (0,71-1,04). En las condiciones de este trabajo el grado de concordancia según Landis & Koch fue de casi perfecto a sustancial en todas las situaciones analizadas (AU))

The aim of this study was to assess agreement among different observers in the evaluation of dental resto-rations in panoramic x-rays at the Dental Hospital of the School of Dentistry, University of Buenos Aires. Materials and methods: an ad-hoc form based on the modified Ryge criteria was designed. Five categories were built: presence and type (R), extension (E), and condition (C), of each restoration, if present, pre-sence and condition of endodontic treatment (EN) and presence and type of intra-root anchorage devices (A). After several virtual calibration meetings among the observers with subsequent adjustments in the form, twenty-five panoramic x-rays were randomly selected and all categories were assessed in three teeth (1.1, 1.3 and 1.6) in each image. The assessment was carried out simultaneously and independently by three evaluators, who registered the data in the de-signed form. Agreement was assessed by category and by category/tooth with Fleiss Kappa. Results: category/tooth (95% CI): R/1.1: 0.96(0.90-1.2),1.3: 0.77(0.56-0.99), 1.6:0.92 (0.80-1.03); E/1.1: 0.92 (0.85-1), 1.3: 0.89 (0.73-1.04), 1.6: 0.92 (0.80-1.03); C: 1.1: 0.88 (0.78-0.98), 1.3: 0.74 (0.38-1.10), 1.6: 1 (1-1); EN: 1.1 and 1.3: 1 (1-1), 1.6: 0.90 (0.77-1.04); A: 1.1 and 1.6: 1 (1- 1), 1.3: 0.88 (0.71-1.04). Within the conditions of this study the degree of agreement ac-cording to Landis & Koch was from almost perfect to substantial in all the situations analyzed (AU)

Concordancia de los hallazgos citológicos, colposcópicos e histológicos en lesiones premalignas del cuello uterino / Concordance in cytological, colposcopic and histological findings in premalignant lesions of the cervix

Resumen OBJETIVO: Determinar la concordancia de los hallazgos citológicos, colposcópicos e histopatológicos en lesiones premalignas del cuello uterino. MATERIALES Y MÉTODOS: Estudio transversal, retrospectivo y comparativo, efectuado en la Clínica de Displasias del Hospital General Regional 1 del estado de Querétaro, México, del 1 de enero a diciembre del 2020, con base en la información de los expedientes de mujeres con reporte citológico, colposcópico e histopatológico (biopsia) de lesión intraepitelial de bajo y alto grado. El plan de análisis estadístico incluyó intervalos de confianza para promedios y porcentajes. Se utilizó el Índice de Kappa ponderado para conocer el nivel de concordancia. RESULTADOS: Se analizaron 290 expedientes. La edad promedio de las pacientes fue 36 años, el índice de kappa ponderado fue k = 0.41 (IC95%: 0.33-0.53) para la citología y la colposcopia con un valor moderado (regular). Para la citología y la biopsia fue de k= 0.33 (IC95%: 0.22-0.49) con un valor escaso (medio). En cuanto a la colposcopia y la biopsia fue de k = 0.61 (IC95%: 0.49-0.72) con un valor de buena (sustancial) concordancia. CONCLUSIÓN: Entre la citología y la colposcopia el coeficiente de concordancia fue moderado, para la citología y la biopsia fue escaso, mientras que para la colposcopia y la biopsia fue un sustancial.

Abstract OBJECTIVE: To determine the concordance in cytologic, colposcopic and histopathologic findings in premalignant lesions of the uterine cervix. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Cross-sectional, retrospective and comparative study, carried out in the dysplasia clinic of the Hospital General Regional 1 of the state of Querétaro, Mexico, from January 1 to December 2020, based on information from the records of women with cytology, colposcopy and histopathology (biopsy) report with low- and high-grade intraepithelial lesion. The statistical analysis plan included confidence intervals for averages and percentages. The weighted Kappa Index was used to determine the level of concordance. RESULTS: Two hundred and ninety records were analyzed. The mean age of the patients was 36 years, the weighted kappa index was k = 0.41 (95%CI: 0.33-0.53) for cytology and colposcopy with a moderate value (fair). For cytology and biopsy, it was k= 0.33 (95%CI: 0.22-0.49) with a poor value (medium). For colposcopy and biopsy, it was k = 0.61 (95%CI: 0.49-0.72) with a value of good (substantial) agreement. CONCLUSION: Between cytology and colposcopy the concordance coefficient was moderate, for cytology and biopsy it was poor, while for colposcopy and biopsy it was a substantial.

Curva de aprendizaje de la ecografía renal en una unidad docente pluriprofesional / Renal ultrasound learning curve performed in a multiprofessional teaching unit

Introducción: El objetivo de esta experiencia fue analizar un módulo formativo inserto en la práctica asistencial de un departamento de urología con la participación de enfermeras especializadas en ecografía urológica como monitoras. Material y métodos: Participaron en el estudio 12 estudiantes de medicina carentes de cualquier conocimiento de ultrasonografía. Su formación corrió a cargo de dos enfermeras con gran experiencia en ecografía. Después de dos sesiones de entrenamiento, se analizó la concordancia entre sus hallazgos en la exploración de los riñones y los de un urólogo especialista. Para analizar la experiencia desde todos los puntos de vista, se exploró el grado de aceptación del módulo formativo por parte de los usuarios y la tolerancia de los profesionales involucrados en términos de síndrome de desgaste profesional (SDP). Por último, se calcularon los costes. Resultados: El coeficiente kappa de concordancia entre el experto y los estudiantes fue bueno (≥ 0,67) en el 58,3% de los casos. No se detectaron rasgos de SDP entre los involucrados en la experiencia. La participación de las enfermeras como monitoras redujo el coste del operativo en un 25% en comparación con los costes en los que se podría haber incurrido caso de docentes urólogos senior. Conclusiones: Las enfermeras pueden proporcionar los rudimentos de la formación en ecografía a legos en la materia. La exploración de individuos con cálculos renales o ureterohidronefrosis se traduce en una mayor concordancia entre observadores. El usuario involucrado acepta de buen grado la experiencia. El operativo resulta inocuo para el personal participante.

Introduction: The objective of this experience was to analyze a training module inserted in the care practice of an urology department, with the participation of nurses specialized in urological ultrasound as monitors. Material and methods: Twelve medical students with no knowledge of ultrasonography participated in the study. His training was carried out by two nurses with extensive experience in ultrasound. After two training sessions, the agreement between their kidney examination findings and those of a specialist urologist was analyzed. To analyze the experience from all points of view, the degree of acceptance of the training module by the users was explored, as well as the tolerance of the professionals involved in terms of professional burnout syndrome (PBS). Finally, the costs of the operation were calculated. Results: The kappa coefficient of agreement between the expert and the students was good (≥ 0.67) in 58.3% of the cases. No traits of PBS were detected among involved in the experience. The participation of nurses as monitors reduced the cost of the operation by 25% compared to the costs that could have been incurred if they had been senior urologist teachers. Conclusions: Nurses can provide the rudiments of sonography training to laymen. Examination of individuals with kidney stones or ureterohydronephrosis results in greater interobserver agreement. In general, the user involved willingly accepts the experience. The operation is harmless for the participating staff.

Grado de concordancia en una serie de informes de electroencefalogramas ambulatorios del Departamento de Neurofisiología Clínica del Hospital de Clínicas / Coefficient of agreement in a series of reports for ambulatory electroencephalograms at the clinical neurophisiology department of Clinicas Hospital / Grau de concordância em uma série de relatórios de eletroencefalogramas ambulatoriais do Departamento de Neurofisiologia Clínica do Hospital de Clínicas

El electroencefalograma (EEG) es una técnica neurofisiológica encargada de analizar la actividad cerebral utilizada con fines diagnósticos en la epilepsia, pero también en pacientes con encefalopatías agudas y crónicas no epilépticas. Su interpretación debe realizarse por médicos especializados en el área con una formación correcta, actualizada y homogénea para evitar conclusiones disimiles y términos en desuso. Para conocer dentro de una unidad de Neurofisiología Clínica de manera objetiva cómo se interpreta un EEG y su concordancia, comparamos una serie de estudios de EEG ambulatorios a través del grado de concordancia o Kappa entre los observadores. Creemos que es importante conocer las similitudes o diferencias inter observador a fines de corregir los problemas observados y mejorar la calidad asistencial.

An electroencephalogram (EEG) is a neurophysiological technique that measures electrical activity in the brain for diagnostic purposes in epilepsy, and in patients with nonepileptic acute and chronic encelopathies. This test must be performed by physicians who are specialized in the area and have the appropriate updated and uniform training, in order to avoid dissimilar conclusions and outdated terms. We compared a series of ambulatory EEG by analyzing the Kappa or coefficient of agreement rate among observers to objectively learn how an EEG is interpreted and about agreement rates at the Neurophisiology Clinic. We believe it is important to learn about interobserver similarities and differences to allow for the correction of problems noticed and improve the quality of care. Coefficient of agreement in a series of reports for ambulatory electroencephalograms at the clinical neurophisiology department of Clinicas Hospital.

O eletroencefalograma (EEG) é uma técnica neurofisiológica utilizada no estudo da atividade cerebral utilizada no diagnóstico em epilepsia, mas também em pacientes com encefalopatias não epilépticas agudas e crônicas. Sua interpretação deve ser realizada por médicos especialistas na área com formação correta, atualizada e homogênea para evitar conclusões díspares e termos obsoletos. Para conhecer como um EEG e sua concordância são interpretados objetivamente dentro de uma unidade de Neurofisiologia Clínica, comparamos uma série de estudos EEG ambulatoriais através do grau de concordância ou Kappa entre observadores. Acreditamos que é importante conhecer as semelhanças ou diferenças interobservadores para corrigir os problemas observados e melhorar a qualidade do atendimento.